Showing posts with label book vs movie. Show all posts
Showing posts with label book vs movie. Show all posts

Monday, March 17, 2014

Austenland: The Movie vs. The Book / Midnight in Austenland

I never thought I'd be saying this . . . but see the movie before you read the book. There - I said it.

Let me start from the beginning: Austenland: A Novel

Austenland: A Novel, written by the brilliant Shannon Hale, is a theme-park of sorts, a place where guests are immersed in the regency period, playing a character right out of one of Jane Austen's novels. The ladies play Whist, learn embroidery, play the pianoforte, and generally learn what it was like to live in a long ago time. In turn, they interact with the manor's gentlemen actors, each experiencing romance.

As a Jane fan, and an actor, I absolutely adore this concept! Were I single, I think it would be great fun to visit a place like this. I'd love the acting, the clothes, the manners and the pretend romance. Well, I'd love it for about a week. I wouldn't last the 3-week stay portrayed in the book.

In the book, the story begins when Jane Hayes, a 30-something obsessed with Mr. Darcy from Pride & Prejudice, is willed a trip to Austenland by her late aunt. Once there, she becomes Jane Erstwhile. Also along on the trip are Miss Heartwright and Miss Charming. While there are hints of personality in all 3 characters, they never fully reach their potential in the story, remaining rather vanilla. Even the male actor characters, Colonel Andrews, Mr. Nobley, Captain George East and Theo the gardener remain middle-of-the-road. I honestly didn't feel anything for any one of the characters. Of course I wanted Jane to find love in the end, but there was really no chemistry between Jane and the man she ultimately found love with.

Overall, I could have skipped the book and just watched the movie, which I highly recommend. Even if you decide to read the book, please watch the movie first. Here's why: